First listed Dec 2025 · 100% positive feedback

Gotham Trading NY

Patek Philippe 31 Rolex 14 Audemars Piguet 11 Vacheron Constantin 2 Omega 2 FP Journe 1 Piaget 1 Breguet 1

Active on

Rolex Forums

Listings 64

Reviews 5 (100%)

Median Price $49,749

Price Range $11,800 – $206,400

A. Lange & Sohne A. Lange & Söhne 1815 F.A. Lange 200th Anniv 40mm Silv… $54,999
Rolex Forums 3 days ago
Audemars Piguet MINT AP Royal Oak Offshore Diver 42mm Black Dial 15720… $34,999
Rolex Forums 3 days ago
Patek Philippe 2026 Patek Philippe Complications Annual Calendar Trav… $67,199
Rolex Forums 4 days ago
Patek Philippe 2026 Patek Philippe Calatrava 38mm Salmon Dial 6169P U… $51,999
Rolex Forums 4 days ago
Patek Philippe 2026 Patek Philippe Twenty~4 Quartz 25mm Purple Dial 4… $42,499
Rolex Forums 4 days ago
Patek Philippe 2026 Patek Philippe Calatrava 41mm Blue Dial 5328G Unw… $65,299
Rolex Forums 6 days ago
Patek Philippe 2026 Patek Philippe Complications Annual Calendar 38mm… $43,199
Rolex Forums 6 days ago
Omega Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra 150M 41.5mm Grey Dial 231.5… $31,699
Rolex Forums 2 weeks ago
Vacheron Constantin VC 2026 FRESH DATE Historiques 222 37mm Blue Dial 4200… $57,599
Rolex Forums 3 weeks ago
Rolex Rolex Submariner Date 40mm Black Dial 116618LN Pre-Own… $31,900
Rolex Forums 3 weeks ago

View All Listings by Gotham Trading NY →

100%

Positive feedback Based on 5 reviews across all sources

Gotham Watch Trading NY

Gotham Watch Trading NY Great Service… Highly Recommend. Thank you Nathan Excellent Service!!!

Rich7500

Rolex Forums 6 months ago View on Rolex Forums →

Gotham Trading NY - Highly Recommend

Gotham Trading NY - Highly Recommend First transaction with Nathan from Gotham Trading NY and it was a smooth transaction from beginning to end. He even answered my call on a Sunday to answer some questions I had. Price was fair and first class service all around. Will definitely do business again with them.

stylus1133

Rolex Forums 8 months ago View on Rolex Forums →

Gotham Trading NY Negative Experience

Watch listed as mint. Took to Lange within 2 weeks of purchase and they noted a big dent between two parts of the case due to excessive polishing after the watch was taken apart which they suggested i fix with them. Seller asks for 2k restocking fee. Would not deal with this seller. I have excellent references from Takuya and …

AficionadoRolex

Rolex Forums 2 years ago View on Rolex Forums →

Gotham Trading NY is the real deal

First transaction with Gotham Trading NY. Very communicative and professional. Highly recommended, buy with confidence!

vsnare

Rolex Forums 3 years ago View on Rolex Forums →

Gotham Trading NY is legit!

Pre-shipped to Nathan at Gotham Trading- wire was processed as soon as I sent them my details. No worries dealing with them at all! Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk

Chris85

Rolex Forums 3 years ago View on Rolex Forums →